Q&A with Pat Shand

CharmedComicFan10 is going to have an exclusive interview with Pat Shand in a few days.

Pat will also reveal the cover for Charmed Season 10 #3 cover in it. 

As always with Q&As i ask for your help. Leave your question ideas below and i will pick some of them for the interview. 

Write a comment

Comments: 39
  • #1

    DC (Monday, 08 September 2014 14:06)

    Привет из Санкт-Петербурга (Россия)! Спасибо Вам за будущий 10 сезон! Огромная просьба - пусть Билли появится хотя бы в роли камео! И хочется встречи с Дэном и Дженни. Успехов!

  • #2

    DC (Monday, 08 September 2014 14:07)

    Greetings from St. Petersburg (Russia)! Thank you for the next 10 season! Huge request - let Billy appears at least a cameo role! And I want to meet with Dan and Jenny. Good luck!

  • #3

    Bigbear (Monday, 08 September 2014 14:53)

    I don't know if it's been asked already, but can you maybe ask him if Prue is ever gonna have a chance to be happy and have a semi-normal life? I get that she should be happy to have any kind of life at all, but being stuck in a fake house with a ghost in the middle of nowhere.. sounds hardly fair.

    And please tell him that just for the way he's been treating us fans in the last few months.. he's all kind of awesome!

  • #4

    Jluengo25 (Monday, 08 September 2014 14:58)

    Hi! I like to know more thigs about Prue. She is dead or alive? i mean she is in the nexus but whats means to her? She miss her old life? (season 1-3?) any chance we see her after she die in season 3? (dosent matter if we see her in third person or even with the Patience face since that is her new body). We see her using telekinesis, she still has her astral proyection power? She is no longer a charmed one but she is still part of Halliwell witches line?

    Thanks! :D

  • #5

    Henry (Monday, 08 September 2014 15:02)

    Ok, maybe I asked too much.. But here's my questions:

    Hello Pat! I have read that this season you will focus on the limits of magic. Could you explain it? I mean, in the Charmed world they often say "the magic has consequences and limits" but many times we have seen the rules of magic bow to the demands of the sisters (the genius who resurrects Prue in the season 2 finale, for example, or the constant trips in time to change the past). I wish these limits were specified! All witches can travel back in time (or only the Charmed Ones)? It 's always possible to change the past (or you can just change what was never supposed to happen)? Why can someone be saved and others can't (as Prue)? And speaking of limits, Wyatt and Billie's projection power seems too powerful to me...
    I also read that this season will focus on demons. We'll find out why low-level demons have human form?
    We'll find out in detail what happened to Prue's soul? Why now her soul has Patience appearance? (In season 9 finale it's said something but not in detail).
    We'll find out something about Patience (before her body was possessed by Prue)?
    We'll see "ordinary" witches? It would be interesting to find their way to fight demons and forces of evil (since many of these creatures can be vanquished only by the Power of Three).
    A big greeting from Italy!

  • #6

    TomTom (Monday, 08 September 2014 16:00)

    Wow, this is so great! An exclusive interview with Pat Shand! Good luck with that and have fun!

    I have some questions too:


    - will Phoebe get in trouble with her feelings to Coop and Cole? I imagine it is hard for her, to get Cole around her again. But...after all this years of fight, she only belongs to Coop I guess.
    - is Pipers new power some kind of useful? Why would she use this heating/melting power, when she can blow up the villains?
    - is it possible to create a flashback episode so we could learn more about Paiges life before meeting her sisters? Or about Pettys life?
    - what exactly was Leo, when he got wings and the sword? A special kind of angel? Like archangel or something? Is he a full-mortal again after losing the wings? I would like it, if he could stay without powers.
    - could Prue/Patience get longer hair? xD
    -does Barbas will ever return? Or is he gone forever? Fear never dies...
    - will we ever see a christmas-epsiode?

    I could go on and on and on... ^^
    Please send him best wishes from Germany! And a big THANK YOU for his great work!

    Oh, I'm still so excited about the cover. Paige is my favourite!! :)

  • #7

    p3nathan (Monday, 08 September 2014 16:07)

    If you could sum up what you are going to explore with each sister this season, using one word or one sentence each, what would they be?

    What was your favourite issue of season 9 and why?

    Which secondary character (as in character who isn't a Halliwell sister) have you enjoyed writing most?

  • #8

    Miia (Monday, 08 September 2014 17:13)

    - what's your favorite Charmed tv-episode?
    - which witch power would you choose if you could?
    - who's the demon you hate the most?
    - did u ever met someone of the Charmed cast or crew? whom?
    - will we see a magical transformation in season 10? Like in the past when Paige turned into a vampire, Phoebe into a Banshee or Piper into a Wendigo...

  • #9

    Julie (Monday, 08 September 2014 20:25)

    Will we find out what Cole did with his fathers soul after he killed Raynor?

    Are demons descended from the Old Ones or are you doing your your own take of the Old Ones?

    Does Phoebe still have feelings for Cole again now that he kinda is back in her life again and will we see some drama unfolding between her love for both Coop and Cole this season?

    Will Andy return this season?

  • #10

    Julie (Monday, 08 September 2014 21:22)

    Ok just a couple questions more and I'll be done

    Did something happen between 4 and 5 that made Phoebe decide not to be with Cole anymore because the change from the finale of 4 to 5 seemed really odd to me?

    How come the Elders didn't know that Cole was going to be the new source in Season 4 and did Cole take in the Sources powers or his essence or what?

  • #11

    Jluengo25 (Tuesday, 09 September 2014 04:14)

    I have some questions more!
    Firts, any chance wee see Patience/Prue with the outfits she used while she was alive?
    What thinks Phoebe of the relationship between Cole and Prue?
    Which sister will miss the most to Prue this season?
    Is Prue safe of the angel of death? I mean, she was dead for a long time and her life was really over and then she take the body of a witch (Patience) but she break all the rules doing that... what is the price?

    Thaks! :D

  • #12

    LeoVzlaP3 (Tuesday, 09 September 2014 07:31)

    - Please ask him is there is going to be a Spanish translation for LatinAmerican fans.

    -Will future Wyatt and Chris be back in an Issue?

    -Will Barbas be back again?

    These are all from me, and It means a lot if yoy ask about the translation I'd love to get them in my language Blessed Be!


  • #13

    Lisa (Tuesday, 09 September 2014 10:04)

    - Will we get to see the four sisters bonding together and will Paige and Prue get some alone time?
    - Will the sisters ever leave San Fransisco even once, even just a holiday or trip?
    - Any plans to bring Andy back, he never made a comeback since his death way back in season 1.
    - Is Prue going to be stuck in her nexas manor forever, is it possible her astro projection powers would allow her to physically be in two places at once and still remain at her post in her manor?

  • #14

    Mia (Tuesday, 09 September 2014 10:06)

    Will Paige and Prue get some bonding moments, and even a solo storyline in any future issues?

  • #15

    Superlana (Tuesday, 09 September 2014 13:53)

    I only have three questions:

    1) Will we see Cupid's Temple again.
    2) Will Phoebe and Coop's relationship be explored.
    3) Will we see a power of two team up of Phoebe and Paige kicking ass together.

    Considering their power set number 3 could be very interesting.

  • #16

    Pavel Ana (Tuesday, 09 September 2014 13:55)

    Hi I have the following questions:
    1)Will Phoebe find out that Cole became the source to save her and her sisters?
    2) Any plans for Phoebe and Cole?
    3) Will we learn some information about Phoebe's and Cole's baby?
    Thank you!

  • #17

    lilchi721 (Tuesday, 09 September 2014 17:25)

    Howdy Pat!
    1)In Season 9 we learned where witches and warlocks get their powers from.... will we find out where demons get their powers from?
    2)If evil wanted "The All" all along then why do they want the Book of Shadows then?
    3)What exactly did the elders put Phoebe through to make her deserve Coop when all the series it seemed like the elders were interfering with Piper and Leo's love life? Just wondering maybe this could be explained in a latter issue.
    4)Any plans for Phoebe and Cole this season?
    5)Will something happen to Coop in the distant future since Wyatt didn't seem to recognize Coop until Piper gave Coop his ring back and in the flash forward we never saw them beyond their third daughter being born in the season 8 finale?
    6)How dark will charmed become this season?

  • #18

    Zoe (Tuesday, 09 September 2014 17:50)

    Hi I want to know if we will have more information about Cole's family, if Cole and Phoebe will be together again, if we will see Prue and Paige bonding more and if their plans include Phoebe and Coop to divorce me and many other people we encourage them.

  • #19

    Shaffy (Tuesday, 09 September 2014 19:13)

    YEEES!!! PLEASE!!! BILLIE COME BAAACK!!!

  • #20

    Mihai (Tuesday, 09 September 2014 19:26)

    Aloha! So my questions are:
    1) If they are going to torture us with Coop's presence (I hope they won't do that) how do they plan to make Coop more interesting because most people violently dislike him, they consider him boring.
    2) Phoebe and Cole together any chance for that?
    3) Prue is she going to have a normal life meaning to get married, have kids?
    4)Prue is she dead or not because I am confused
    That is all

  • #21

    Steph (Wednesday, 10 September 2014 09:48)

    Hi Pat!
    - Will Andy come back or do you intend to make a new love interest for Prue?
    - This season the girls will get new powers?
    - Most people including me want Phoebe and Cole back together what is your opinion about that?
    - Any plans for the Seer to come back?
    Thank you and good luck with the new season!

  • #22

    Miia (Wednesday, 10 September 2014 13:32)

    O people! Be realistic!
    Phoebe + Cole? Your love for this couple isn't enough to bring it back. It's over. The life isn't a place where every wish come true. It would be a betrayal of the TV show and the characters to reanimate this love.
    Phoebe and Cole are wonderful together, but it would be sooo unrealistic to bring them back together...
    Be objective, not subjective!

    Sorry, i had to say it. xD
    I laugh this couple too, but... it wouldn't work anymore...

  • #23

    Henry (Wednesday, 10 September 2014 14:20)

    @Miia Finally someone said that! Like most of you, I think Coop is terribly boring and I loved Phoebe and Cole but there's no future for them (litterally because we saw their future).. I hope Pat will make Coop more interesting.. And I think that the same is for Andy's return.. I liked his character but I don't think we'll see him again, at least not as we remember him! It would be weird and too fan-fictionaly (I don't know if this word exists XD).. that's why I loved Patience's story! It was so naturally and plausible.. If Andy will come back, I hope his return will be original like the Prue's one! Stop with simple ghostly visits..

  • #24

    Miia (Wednesday, 10 September 2014 14:34)

    Wow, Henry!
    Fan-fictionaly!! Perfect! This is the word that describes this wish the best! :D

  • #25

    Pavel Ana (Wednesday, 10 September 2014 14:36)

    Hi Mia you are right I don't think that they intend to do that although many people hate Coop. I think most people realize that but they've just asked a question because they really love this couple and most people were really disappointed of the way that Phoebe and Cole's story ended.

  • #26

    Stan (Wednesday, 10 September 2014 14:36)

    Hi people,
    Well my questions are similar to what other people have asked here. Miia a question wasn't it a betrayal of the TV show when they rushed the ending and told us that Coop is Phoebe's true love. I mean what did he do for her, there is no chemestry between them, no passion, nothing. They did the same thing with Paige and Henry but at least at them they tried harder, it makes sense, they are not boring. If they want to bring them together they can create the proper context, not like this out of the blue, I wouldn't like it like this. In here is a question of wanting if they want to do that they can do it in a creative way in order to make sense. Sorry for my English is not so good.

  • #27

    Stan (Wednesday, 10 September 2014 14:41)

    Future has changed many times during the show, it can be changed again.

  • #28

    p3nathan (Wednesday, 10 September 2014 16:07)

    While I find Coop incredibly boring and did enjoy Phoebe and Cole in season 3 and 4... I would much rather Coop was developed into an interesting character than have Phoebe ditch are husband; the father of her children, to be with a guy she detested not so long a go. I really can't see how Phoebe would come out of that looking anything but absolutely terrible. Besides, Cole's ultimate goal is to move on, so where would that leave her?

  • #29

    p3nathan (Wednesday, 10 September 2014 16:08)

    Paul did a good job expanding the cupid mythology in season 9; I found Coop a bit more sympathetic. But there's still a way to go.

  • #30

    Julie (Wednesday, 10 September 2014 16:15)

    Well we really don't know what's in store for Phoebe and Coops future cause when Phoebe is pregnant with her third daughter in the flash forward of forever charmed it was 7 or 8 years after season 8 so beyond that we don't know if they will be together forever. Plus future Wyatt didn't even recognize Coop until Piper gave Coop his ring back and then Wyatt suddenly blurts it out.I think it's a possibility something happens to Coop sometime in the future.

  • #31

    Miia (Wednesday, 10 September 2014 16:26)

    @ Stan:
    I personally think that Cole is Phoebes true love. And will ever be! Her one and only.
    I guess the writers forgot the fact, that the name of her true love begins with a "C" (like it is showin in season 3 (odd oracle! which other letter could this apple skin form into? perhaps a G...)) and Coop's name is just a coincidence. It was never said, that only Coop was meant with this omen...

    Don't get me wrong: I don't like Coop very much. I love Cole! He should be Phoebes soulmate. He is, it's showin in season 7...
    But after all this fight, hate, death and new love it wouldn't work anymore. It would be to constructed. Only for fulfilling the fans wishes...

    I wish it would be otherwise (Cole without (demonic) powers, as her husband and father of her kids).
    Phoebe has to let the past behind her. She's strong she can do it!

  • #32

    Miia (Wednesday, 10 September 2014 16:30)

    But I have to say: I like the idea you metionend, Julie! Would be interesting to know, if this is any intent...

  • #33

    Zoe (Wednesday, 10 September 2014 18:59)

    But what if Coop would cheat Phoebe, or if Phoebe would discover that he has other family come on there are a lot of possibilities to put them back together without making Phoebe look horrible. I bet they can come with much better ideas than me because they are very talented people. As Stan is saying it is a question about wanting. I mean they should listen to what fans are saying, because we also contributed to the success of this show and of course thanks to their talent let's not forget that.

  • #34

    TomTom (Wednesday, 10 September 2014 19:08)

    A cupid that cheats his love...? Hm, I think that would be an unlogical plot...
    But I agree, they could find a way to let Coop go. Coop is the first cupid who loves isn't he? His ring could get stolen (like it is in season 2). And the thief destroys not only the love Coop finds for others but even HIS OWN love, so Coop dies. In Phoebes arms. ;)

  • #35

    charmedcomicfan10 (Wednesday, 10 September 2014 19:12)

    Thank you for submitting Qs, guys. I sent Pat the final Qs today.

  • #36

    p3nathan (Thursday, 11 September 2014 01:10)

    Sure, maybe Coop is a cheater or has a family somewhere...and maybe it was actually Andy's never before mentioned identical twin that died in 1x22 and the real Andy is in hiding somewhere, so he can have a happy life with Prue after all. o_O

    Whatever happens, Coop is at least sticking around until Phoebe baby no.3 comes along (which won't be this season). I personally would like for Cole's story line not to start revolving around Phoebe again; I'm actually liking him outside of that one tired "gotta get Phoebe back" story line. But we'll see what develops I guess.



  • #37

    Julie (Thursday, 11 September 2014 15:38)

    What if they made a story line where Phoebe and Cole didn't expect to fall back in love with each other in the future or would that be to much like a fan fiction story?

  • #38

    Zoe (Thursday, 11 September 2014 17:41)

    @P3nathan I was just saying that there are ways if they want to do that. Now thinking about it it is true what Tom is saying that a cupid cheating his love is an unlogical plot. @ Julie that is a really great idea I like it.

  • #39

    seks telefony (Wednesday, 18 January 2017 17:09)

    wideofilm