Discuss Charmed Season 10 #17

Comments: 25 (Discussion closed)
  • #1

    Frankie (Thursday, 03 March 2016 01:24)

    It was a good issue. All of the anger and resentment that Prue had towards her family were coming to fruition. She was angry with Victor for not understanding/mourning her death. She nearly killed him by choking him until Piper came. Piper realized that something was wrong with Prue. Prue's next target was Phoebe who was babysitting the kids for Piper and Paige. Prue started telling the kids a story of the Old Ones and Phoebe overheard her and sent the kids away. Prue the pulled out the soul destroying athame on Phoebe. Phoebe then attacked Prue with a levitated kick but Prue hit her with an energy blast pushing her thru a wall. On the ground crying, Prue approaches Phoebe. She's about to stab Phoebe with the athame and Prue says she meant something to her before she abandoned her family for a demon (Cole). Prue ask why she didn't mourn for her angrily about to stab her. Then Phoebe says she did mourn her and then she used her Empathy in time to stop her from stabbing her. Phoebe says she needs to show Prue who she really is. Prue thinks Phoebe tried to kill her but Phoebe said she knew she could handle her Empathic assault. Prue tries to stab Phoebe again until Tyler creates a portal that Prue falls into. Piper and Paige come with Tyler while Piper consoles a tearful Phoebe

  • #2

    41eugoR (Thursday, 03 March 2016 08:06)

    O.0 I so wish I didn't read the spoilerish comment. I need get my hands on the issue now.

  • #3

    Anne (Thursday, 03 March 2016 10:34)

    Poor Prue, I hope her sisters save her otherwise its death.

  • #4

    Savage (Thursday, 03 March 2016 10:36)

    Oh gosh Prue please don't be killed.

  • #5

    Sally (Thursday, 03 March 2016 13:20)

    What is going on with Prue. I will be so angry if shes killed off by seasons end.

  • #6

    Wesley (Thursday, 03 March 2016 13:21)

    Aww exciting issue, anything more that went on, where Kyra and Ben in the issue?

  • #7

    Frankie (Thursday, 03 March 2016 16:29)

    @Wesley yea Jara and Ben were in it but they're so boring and irrelevant to me. I just focused on the sisters. I liked the Prue vs Phoebe action. Y'all should check it out

  • #8

    Frankie (Thursday, 03 March 2016 16:30)

    I meant to say Kyra*

  • #9

    paradosso_ontologico (Thursday, 03 March 2016 18:33)

    This issue is AMAZING! Any chance we're to read an interview with Pat soon?

  • #10

    CharmedComicFan10 Kostas (Thursday, 03 March 2016 18:44)

    Interview with Pat is ready. Will post it today.

  • #11

    41eugoR (Thursday, 03 March 2016 18:45)

    I wasn't expecting Prue to go all evil on her sisters or Dad in this issue. Wonder how her dramatic meeting with Tribunal will go now. And why the Tribunal would even want Prue anywhere near them.

  • #12

    spiros (Thursday, 03 March 2016 19:45)

    I think Tyler put Prue in his effigy..

  • #13

    pruefan4life (Thursday, 03 March 2016 19:53)

    That's an awesome theory @spiros! There was something about that last frame with Tyler's effigy that was gnawing at me!

  • #14

    spiros (Thursday, 03 March 2016 21:23)

    Thank you @pruefan4life but now that I have read the interview I know its not that. Well to be honest I didn't really expect to be right :P anyway what an amazing issue

  • #15

    Tom (Thursday, 03 March 2016 22:57)

    I like how powerful Phoebe has become. She was able to stop Prue

  • #16

    LeoVzla (Friday, 04 March 2016 04:13)

    I can't believe after all this time and after Pat has denied over and over again, Pleople think Prue is going to die... Either way It's everyone's opinion.

    What I liked the most was that we finally saw a sort of answer gor all of us who thought Phoebe didn't mourn Prue as Piper did.

    I alsp love how Prue is finally revelling how she really feels about everything after her death, can't wait for the 4th arc!!!

  • #17

    Frankie (Friday, 04 March 2016)

    @LeoVzla yea I didn't like how Phoebe only mourned her for like 2 episodes and Piper mourned for her and mentioned her throughout the series even tho Phoebes worst fear was losing a sister. You would think she would've taken it the hardest. Hopefully Phoebe and Prue get to bond over this.

  • #18

    Pat Shand (Friday, 04 March 2016 05:13)

    I definitely didn't deny that Prue was going to die. I didn't deny or confirm any deaths, and would never do that. Anyone can die. I don't care about anyone guessing deaths before hand, I don't care about any comments like that. All a storyteller should care about is telling the best story, regardless of what people are saying -- and that's what I'm going to do! In the end, when you guys see the full shape of the season, you'll see what I mean.

    I just think it's funny that folks are collectively trying to guess the end while I'm still withholding a LOT of information!

  • #19

    Pat Shand (Friday, 04 March 2016 07:11)

    Sorry, meant to type "was or wasn't going to die." sorry!

  • #20

    v-girl (Friday, 04 March 2016 19:00)

    But Frankie, not everyone grieves in the exact same way. Not everybody bursts into tears for days and days, some internalize a lot more. It doesn't mean that they're not mourning in their own way. Phoebe cried on occasion, but she mostly decided to distract herself by sorting things out and trying to save Paige. Looking for distractions from the pain isn't an unusual way of trying to cope.

  • #21

    CharmedAgain4 (Friday, 04 March 2016 19:01)

    Pat's answer is exactly why I still have a sinking feeling that Prue could die at the end of this season because he has never confirmed nor denied it. We need to be thinking what would Prue's second death mean for the season.

  • #22

    CharmedAgain4 (Friday, 04 March 2016 19:05)

    @v-girl I guess we can say that Phoebe hid her feelings about Prue's death by distracting herself with her love for Cole, her work, and demons. It would make the most sense that she internalized her feelings because she became the middle sister, just like Piper did when she was the middle sister of Prue and Phoebe.

  • #23

    Frankie (Friday, 04 March 2016 20:01)

    @vgirl I understand people grieve differently but we didn't really see much of it from Phoebe. She cried at her funeral then again when they were trying to save Paige then that was it. I liked that in centennial charmed she promised to stay with Cole so that "What happened to Prue doesn't happen to Piper". But she never really acknowledges Prue throughout the show, especially with losing her being her worst fear. I thought maybe it had something to do with whatever tension was between Alyssa and Shannen but I still would've liked to see more from Phoebe, like guilt of not being able to use her psychic powers to save her. Hopefully Pat expands on Prue's resentment towards Phoebe and Phoebes pain for Prue.

    It's the perfect chance for Phoebe to use her Empathic abilities to truly see and understand what Prue is and was going thru

  • #24

    Val (Saturday, 05 March 2016 13:29)

    I think when it came to mourning Prue, Phoebe was just more "practical", so to speak. She definitely kept distracting herself from the pain by being immersed into work, Cole and, what was more important, revenge. Think about it. It was Phoebe who was really determined in destroying Shax avenging for Prue's death. It was Phoebe who kept pushing Piper towards battling the Source in "Brain Drain" reminding her that they still have to destroy the Source for Prue's sake, if not for their's. And it was Phoebe who was the first to raise her glass to Prue after they vanquished the Source in "Charmed and Dangerous". Maybe she was seeking for an atonement to redeem herself because she was partially blaming herself for Prue's demise. I tend to think that when she mourned Cole in "Long Live the Queen" she was also mourning Prue because her love for Cole and her willingness to turn him good in 3x22 got her big sister killed. What is more important, Prue refers to Phoebe abandoning her family for a demon in this issue when in "Wrestling with demons" Prue kinda foreshadowed her death saying that what Phoebe had done was out of love "that almost got all of us killed".

  • #25

    41eugoR (Saturday, 05 March 2016 19:14)

    @Val: Wow....Never really noticed these things until you mentioned it. I guess Piper's grief for Prue's death may have overshadowed it. Also could it be that Phoebe didn't want to breakdown and lose it completely since she was vulnerable to turning evil? She already saw her future self killing Cal Greene for vengeance for a dear friend and the consequences of it. Experienced her past life planning to kill her own family for love of a warlock. If she wasn't practical about her grief and let herself be consumed by vengenace only who knows what would've happened.